Just renewed my car insurance, and reasonably happy.
Was with Hastings Direct and went online to get quotes for renewals.
Only one quote cheaper than Hastings, but by the time you added on the extras, it made it more expensive.
Got a quote of £186 for their standard insurance (fully comp + no claims protection etc) or £226 for their premier service.
Next day I get my renewal quote through the post from them - £272, which was £40 more than last year.
Straight on the phone, told them I had a cheaper quote on line (direct from their site, not comparison sites, which quoted about 2 - 3 pound higher on each of the quotes from Hastings).
It annoys me that we have to perform this song and dance every year now, but he was able to do me the Premier insurance for £225, which also includes breakdown cover (roadside assistance and recovery), no compulsory excess, legal cover and all the normal extras. So not only was the insurance £15 cheaper than last year, but saves me near on £100 on breakdown cover for the year ahead.
Can't really grumble at that.