Only someone with the blinkered mindset of the Ninty fan would believe that resistive is better than capacitive on a game controller.
Resistive plus points
It's more accurate if you're using a stylus (but who's going to be using a stylus on a gamepad?)
It's very cheap.
Capacitive plus points
It's more intuitive. (A quick light tap with the pad of your finger would work fine. It wouldn't with resistive)
It's more flexible. (Multitouch is pretty essential for web-viewing on a small handheld screen. Would also be handy in lots of games and other applications.
It feels much nicer. (Sliding your finger over a glass screen is so much better than sliding it over several squishy layers of resistive plastic.)
You don't need long girly fingernails, or a stylus. (Who wants to dig out a stylus to do things on the fly on a touchscreen in a game?)
Sounds like you haven't used a resistive touchscreen for a while.
A quick light tap with your finger works fine these days. Both are intuitive.
Web browsing is fine on the GamePad. Instead of using your fingers to pinch zooming in and out you have a + and - button. There's really not a great deal of difference tbh.
It feels nicer..? Really..? lol
You don't need girly long fingernails or a stylus to use the touchscreen. I've only used the stylus when drawing stuff on Miiverse, which Sony will probably clone.
Miiverse (and any clones this gen) will have hardly any attraction to people if you couldn't draw stuff. I can't imagine how poor the art will be if Sony produce a controller with a capacitive touchscreen which forces people to draw with stubby fingers when posting art on PS4verse. Stuff like this will be impossible:
The artwork on Miiverse is amazing and is fundamental to its success. If/when Sony and Microsoft 'borrow' the idea they'll need to have a resistive touchscreen otherwise it's going to be a shadow of Miiverse without the sort of artwork above.
The only advantage that a capacitive touchscreen has over the resistive touchscreen is being able to pinch to zoom in and out, as far as game control goes it's unneccessary to have multitouch because you have, as I've already mentioned, two bloody great big analog sticks and a shitload of buttons. If smartphones had analog sticks and buttons you wouldn't need a capacitive touchscreen for gaming on those devices either.